|
|
Advantages and Disadvantages of the "Free Web"
Warning: Anyone can publish a web page to support their own intents and purposes. Content on the World Wide Web varies from high-quality research to biased or misleading promotional materials to downright misinformation. The amount of scholarly information available varies by subject.
Evaluating
a web page is a critical part of your research. When you review
your search results, consider:
- Author/Producer's Credibility - Can you identify who produced the page, his/her professional affiliation and expertise? can you contact the author?
- Point of View - Does the author acknowledge and refer to other research or opinions on the topic? is the presentation fair and balanced? is the author trying to sell something?
- Accuracy - Is there evidence of quality control? is the page detailed and factual?
- Relevance - Is the page appropriate for the target audience? is it appropriate for your topic?
- Timeliness - Is the copyright or "last updated" date from the last month, few months, year?
- Comprehensiveness - Are other sources presented? does the author address the subject with appropriate breadth and depth?
These are factors in the mind's of librarians when they select items for our collections. See the Subject Research Guides for lists of useful materials.
Positive Features of the Web |
Negative Features of the Web |
| Current, topical information, such as news from around the world |
Information which has not been edited or proven. |
| Information about companies and organizations. |
Limitations on what companies post on the Web. |
| Information published by government agencies. |
Costly or "invisible," information. |
| Information on topics or by authors without access to mainstream publishing venues. |
Volatility of file location and availability. |
| Information purchased and organized by libraries. |
Historical information, subscription databases and other important information may not be available. |
| Multimedia resources such as sounds, images, and video. |
Connection and download time may be extremely slow. |
|